Infield Fly Rule Explained: When It Applies in Baseball
A batter pops the ball straight up over the infield. The umpire raises an arm, shouts two words, and the batter walks back to the dugout — even though nobody caught the ball. Fans in the stands look at each other. The runner on first stays put. Nothing about the play looks fair, yet the call is right.
This guide explains the rule from the ground up: what it says, the four conditions that must all be true, why baseball needs it, what runners and fielders should do when it is called, and where fans most often get it wrong. If you are new to the sport, our baseball rules for beginners covers the basics first.
Quick Answer
Table of Contents
- What Is the Rule?
- A Short History of the Rule
- The Four Conditions That Must All Be True
- Why the Rule Exists: The Cheap Double Play
- What Happens After the Call
- What the Runners Should Do
- What the Batter and the Fielders Should Do
- The Umpire’s Job: Ordinary Effort and the Signal
- When the Call Is Cancelled: The Foul Ball Exception
- The Intentional Drop Rule: A Different Rule
- The Rule in Softball and Youth Baseball
- The Most Famous Call: The 2012 Wild Card Game
- Common Mistakes Fans Make
- Frequently Asked Questions
What Is the Infield Fly Rule?
The rule sits in two places in the Official Baseball Rules: the Definitions of Terms, where “Infield Fly” is defined, and Rule 5.09(a)(5), which says the batter is out when one is declared. The point is protection. Without this rule, a fielder could let an easy pop-up drop on purpose, pick it up, and turn a cheap double play against runners who were pinned near their bases. The rule takes that trick away by declaring the batter out at once, which removes the force play and lets the runners stay where they are.
Three things surprise new fans most. First, the call is made while the ball is still in the air, not after it lands. Second, the batter is out even if the fielder drops the ball or never touches it. Third, the ball stays live after the call.
A Short History of the Rule
The problem the rule solves is as old as organised baseball. In the 1860s, infielders worked out that a pop-up with runners on base was a gift: let it drop, throw to one base, then to another, and collect two outs for the price of none. Runners could not leave their bases while the ball was in the air, because a catch would leave them doubled off.
The National League introduced the rule in 1895 to stop the trick. The current form came into effect in 1901, and it was amended in 1904 so that it does not apply to line drives, and again in 1920 so that it does not apply to bunts.
The Four Conditions That Must All Be True
An umpire can only call the rule when four things are true at the same time. If any one of them is missing, there is no call, and the play is an ordinary fly ball. The table below is the fastest way to check a play.
| Condition | What it means | If it is missing |
|---|---|---|
| Fewer than two outs | Zero outs or one out | With two outs, the defence only needs one out anyway, so the trick has no value |
| Runners on first and second, or the bases loaded | First and second must both be occupied | A runner on first alone, or on first and third, does not count |
| A fair fly ball, not a line drive or a bunt | A pop-up or a regular fly ball in fair territory | Line drives and bunts are never covered |
| Catchable with ordinary effort | An infielder could catch it without an extraordinary play | A ball drifting deep into the outfield or into the stands is not covered |
The second condition trips up the most fans. Runners on first and third do not trigger the rule, because there is no force play at third base, and a runner on second alone does not trigger it either. The force play at third exists only when first and second are both occupied, with or without a runner on third.
“Ordinary effort” is the umpire’s judgment, and it is the heart of the rule. The rulebook says the judgment of the umpire must govern. A routine pop-up to the shortstop is ordinary effort. A ball hit high but drifting toward the outfield grass, where an infielder must sprint and dive, is not. The grass line and the base lines are not the test — the umpire watches the flight of the ball and the fielder’s position, not the chalk.
Why the Rule Exists: The Cheap Double Play
Picture the setup. Runners on first and second, one out, and the batter pops the ball up to the second baseman. The runners must stay close to their bases while the ball is in the air: if the fielder catches it, a runner who has wandered off will be doubled off the base. That freeze is what makes the trick possible.
Without the rule, the second baseman could let the ball drop, pick it up, throw to third for one out, and watch the throw come back to second or first for another. Two outs from a ball the batter hit into the air. The batting team loses a rally it never had a chance to defend, and the defence is rewarded for failing to catch a ball on purpose.
The rule breaks the trick by removing the force. Once the umpire calls it, the batter is out, so no runner is forced to advance. The runners can stay on their bases, and the defence gains nothing by dropping the ball. The rule does not punish the defence for a genuine error — a fielder who drops a pop-up the umpire never called has simply made an error, and the runners may run.
The rule still shapes the modern professional game, where front offices weigh every edge. Our MLB trade rumors guide explains how trades work, the deadline, and how to judge a rumour — the same front-office world in which a single call can swing a close game.

What Happens After the Call
The moment the umpire declares the call, the batter is out. That part is final, with one exception covered in section 9. It does not matter whether the ball is caught, dropped, or left to bounce.
The ball, however, stays live. Runners may advance at their own risk, exactly as on any fly ball. If the ball is caught, a runner must tag up — retouch the base — before advancing, just as on an ordinary caught fly ball. If the ball is not caught, a runner may run without tagging up, but does so at the runner’s own risk, because the ball is live and the defence may throw the runner out.
If the ball is caught
If the ball is caught, the play is treated exactly like an ordinary caught fly ball: the batter is out, there is no force, and the runners must tag up.
What the Runners Should Do
Runners should listen for the call and then think, not run. The call removes the force, so the safest move is usually to stay on the base and watch the ball. A runner who takes off while the ball is in the air risks being doubled off if the ball is caught.
Tag up or run
The right move depends on the catch. If the ball is caught, a runner may tag up and try to advance, but only when the throw is clearly not a threat. If the ball drops untouched, a runner may advance without tagging up, but the ball is live, so a quick fielder can still throw the runner out.
Base coaches earn their pay on this play, watching the ball and shouting instructions, because the runner’s view of the umpire’s raised arm may be blocked. Young runners should be taught one habit above all: freeze on the call, watch the ball, and move only when the coach says so.
College teams play under the same rule, and the same freeze-and-watch habit decides games there too. Our ASU baseball schedule guide shows how to find a college team’s fixtures and follow every game.
One more detail matters. A runner who leaves early on a caught ball and is thrown out has been doubled off the ordinary way — the rule does not protect a runner who runs into an out. The rule protects runners from being forced to run; it does not protect them from bad decisions.
What the Batter and the Fielders Should Do
The batter’s job is simple: run. A batter who hears the call and stops running has still made an out, and a ball that ends up foul would cancel the call and give the batter another chance, so batters who jog to first on every pop-up never get caught out by that exception.
Fielders should catch the ball anyway. A catch lets the defence try to double off a runner who left early, and it keeps the ball from bouncing into trouble. The pitcher and the catcher count as infielders for this rule, and so does any outfielder who has stationed himself in the infield on the play — what matters is the ball and the effort, not which glove ends up under it.
The Umpire’s Job: Ordinary Effort and the Signal
Any umpire on the field may declare the call, and the rule directs the umpire to declare it immediately on determining that the play meets the conditions. The umpire does not wait to see whether the ball is caught. The call is made while the ball is in the air, so that everyone on the field knows the batter is out before the ball comes down.
The signal is unmistakable: the umpire raises the right arm straight up, index finger pointing up, and calls “infield fly” — or, more often, “infield fly, batter is out”. Fans who learn to watch for the raised arm will never be surprised by the call again.
Judgment calls are the hardest part of umpiring, and this one is pure judgment. The umpire must decide in a second or two whether an infielder could have caught the ball with ordinary effort, taking into account the wind, the sun, the spin on the ball, and the fielder’s starting position. The rulebook is explicit that the umpire’s judgment governs, which means the call is not reviewable as a matter of fact in most competitions — a manager may argue, but the judgment stands.
Young players meet this judgment for the first time on their way up, and the MLB draft 2026 file shows how the professional pipeline works for the prospects who will face it next.
That judgment is also why the same-looking play can be called one day and not the next: a pop-up in a swirling wind that forces the shortstop to drift twenty feet is not ordinary effort, while a routine pop-up on a calm day is, even if the fielder misjudges it and the ball drops.
When the Call Is Cancelled: The Foul Ball Exception
There is one situation where the call is undone. If the ball is not caught and ends up foul — including if it lands fair and then rolls foul before passing first or third base without being touched by a fielder — the call is cancelled, and the play is treated as an ordinary foul ball.
The logic is simple: the rule only applies to a fair fly ball. A ball that ends up foul was never a fair fly ball at all, so the rule never truly applied.
Umpires handle the near-the-line case with care. If the fly ball is near the foul lines, the umpire declares “infield fly if fair”, so that everyone knows the call depends on where the ball ends up. That conditional call is the umpire’s way of covering a ball that might drift foul.
This exception is why batters should always run out a pop-up. A ball that looks fair in the air can bounce foul, and a batter who has already walked to the dugout will not be on base to take advantage. It is also why fielders should never assume a ball near the line is foul: a touch by a fielder before it rolls foul keeps it fair, and the call stands.
The Intentional Drop Rule: A Different Rule
Many fans mix up the infield fly with a separate rule, Rule 5.09(a)(12), which covers an infielder who intentionally drops a fair fly ball or line drive. The two rules cover different situations and have different penalties.
The intentional drop rule applies with a runner on first alone, or with runners on first and others, and with fewer than two outs. Unlike the infield fly, it applies to line drives and bunts as well as fly balls. When it is called, the batter is out, the ball is dead, and the runners return to their bases.
The differences are worth learning side by side.
| Feature | Infield fly rule | Intentional drop rule |
|---|---|---|
| Rule number | 5.09(a)(5) | 5.09(a)(12) |
| Needs runners on first and second | Yes | No — a runner on first alone is enough |
| Applies to line drives | No | Yes |
| Applies to bunts | No | Yes |
| Ball after the call | Live | Dead, runners return |
| What the fielder did | Does not matter — the batter is out either way | Must be an intentional drop |
A fielder who lets a ball drop on purpose with a runner on first alone has broken the intentional drop rule, not the infield fly rule. A fielder who drops a routine pop-up with the bases loaded has done nothing wrong at all — the batter is already out, and the drop is just a drop. Knowing which rule applies is the fastest way to sound like an expert in the stands.

The Rule in Softball and Youth Baseball
The rule works the same way in softball as it does in baseball, and for the same reason: to stop the defence from dropping a pop-up on purpose to turn a cheap double play. The conditions are the same — fewer than two outs, runners on first and second or the bases loaded, a fair fly ball that is not a line drive or a bunt, catchable with ordinary effort. Our softball rules for beginners explains the sport’s other shared rules.
Youth leagues use the rule too, though some of the youngest age groups leave it out while players are still learning the game. Coaches of youth teams should check their league’s rulebook before the season, because a local modification can change when the rule is in effect. Where the rule does apply, coaches should teach it early: young runners who learn to freeze on the call save their team from doubled-off outs all season.
College baseball uses the same rule as the professional game, and fans who follow a college team will see it called in exactly the same way. Softball fans can follow their own game the same way: our scores NCAA softball guide explains how to follow every college softball game live.
The college softball season has its own rhythms, and the LSU women’s softball schedule shows how one top programme’s season is laid out.
The SEC baseball standings show how tight conference races get, and a single call in a close game can swing a series.
Score updates work the same way at every level: our MLB scores guide explains how to follow live results, standings and the playoff race.
The Most Famous Call: The 2012 Wild Card Game
The most famous call in the rule’s history came on 5 October 2012, in the National League Wild Card Game between the Atlanta Braves and the St. Louis Cardinals. In the eighth inning, with the Braves trailing 6-3, runners on first and second and one out, Atlanta shortstop Andrelton Simmons hit a pop-up into shallow left field.
Umpire Sam Holbrook, working the left-field line, called the infield fly. Cardinals shortstop Pete Kozma drifted back, the ball dropped between Kozma and left fielder Matt Holliday, and the batter was out. The Braves argued that the ball had travelled too far for an infielder to catch it with ordinary effort, but their protest was denied and the call stood.
Braves fans reacted by throwing debris onto the field, delaying the game while the field was cleared.
Why fans still argue about it
The play is still argued about today, and it is the best lesson in how the rule works: the call turns on the umpire’s judgment of ordinary effort, not on where the ball lands.
Common Mistakes Fans Make
The rule confuses fans more than any other rule in baseball, and the same mistakes come up again and again.
- “The batter is only out if the ball is caught.” No. The batter is out the moment the umpire calls it, caught or not.
- “It applies with a runner on first alone.” No. First and second must both be occupied, or the bases must be loaded.
- “It applies with two outs.” No. With two outs, the defence only needs one out, so there is no cheap double play to prevent, and the rule is not in effect.
- “A line drive counts.” No. Line drives and bunts are never covered, however easy they look. The rule is for fly balls only.
- “The ball is dead after the call.” No. The ball stays live, and runners may advance at their own risk or tag up after a catch.
- “The fielder has to be standing on the infield dirt.” No. The pitcher, the catcher, and any outfielder stationed in the infield count as infielders, and the grass line is not the test. Ordinary effort is the test.
Collectors follow the young players who will face this call for years, and our 2025 Bowman draft checklist is a collector’s guide to the prospects coming through.

Frequently Asked Questions About the Infield Fly Rule
What is the infield fly rule in simple terms?
The batter is automatically out on an easy pop-up when runners are on first and second (or the bases are loaded) and there are fewer than two outs. The umpire calls it while the ball is in the air.
When does the infield fly rule apply?
Four conditions must all be true: fewer than two outs, runners on first and second or the bases loaded, a fair fly ball that is not a line drive or a bunt, and an infielder who could catch it with ordinary effort.
Does the infield fly rule apply with a runner on first only?
No. First and second must both be occupied, or the bases must be loaded.
Does the infield fly rule apply with two outs?
No. With two outs the defence only needs one out anyway, so there is no cheap double play to prevent, and the rule is not in effect.
Is the batter out if the fielder drops the ball?
Yes. The batter is out the moment the umpire declares the call, whether the ball is caught, dropped, or left to bounce. The only exception is if the ball ends up foul.
Can runners advance on an infield fly?
Yes, at their own risk, because the ball stays live. If the ball is caught, runners must tag up first; if it is not caught, they may run without tagging up.
What is the difference between the infield fly rule and the intentional drop rule?
The infield fly rule needs runners on first and second, applies only to fly balls, and leaves the ball live. The intentional drop rule needs only a runner on first, applies to line drives and bunts too, and kills the ball.
Does the infield fly rule apply in softball?
Yes. Softball uses the same rule with the same conditions, for the same reason.
How do umpires signal the infield fly rule?
The umpire raises the right arm straight up, index finger pointing up, and calls “infield fly, batter is out”. Any umpire on the field may make the call.
What happens if the ball lands foul after the call?
The call is cancelled and the play is treated as an ordinary foul ball. The batter is not out.
Share this article: X | Facebook | LinkedIn | Email
Written by Saadi | View all articles by Saadi
Facts checked on 14 November 2026. Sources: the Official Baseball Rules (Definitions of Terms and Rule 5.09(a)(5) and 5.09(a)(12)), Baseball-Reference and Wikipedia for the rule’s history, and Sports Flash Daily’s own baseball guides for the linked articles. The 2012 Wild Card Game account follows the widely reported record of the Braves–Cardinals game of 5 October 2012.



















